75:: The one thing women DON'T need in their exercise handbags

Speaker: 00:00:00

This next part of our exercise handbag

is going to deviate from the series

2

: 00:00:03

just a little bit because it might

not be as essential as we previously

3

: 00:00:07

thought, especially for women.

4

: 00:00:09

So let's clear the air a

bit on zone two training.

5

: 00:00:12

Specifically how zone two

training affects the female body.

6

: 00:00:16

Welcome back to Wellness, fix the Pod.

7

: 00:00:17

I'm your host, Dr.

8

: 00:00:18

Kelsey Vic, a board

certified orthopedic Dr.

9

: 00:00:20

Physical therapy and a pelvic

floor physical therapist.

10

: 00:00:22

And this new series we've been

doing throughout September.

11

: 00:00:26

I'm calling the exercise handbag

series because we are talking about

12

: 00:00:30

some of the essentials to include

in your exercise handbag, where

13

: 00:00:33

we all have different handbags.

14

: 00:00:34

We all have different styles of handbags

that we enjoy, that we gravitate

15

: 00:00:38

towards, just like we have different

forms of exercise that we might

16

: 00:00:41

gravitate towards, but the essentials

in our handbag, the essentials in our

17

: 00:00:44

exercise routine, especially as women.

18

: 00:00:46

Should be pretty similar.

19

: 00:00:47

We have our phones, our keys, our wallets,

just like in our exercise handbag, we also

20

: 00:00:51

have some of the essentials that we want

as foundations in our exercise routine.

21

: 00:00:56

So our first two essentials we

covered were high intensity interval

22

: 00:00:59

training slash sprint interval

training, and then also jump training.

23

: 00:01:02

High intensity interval training.

24

: 00:01:03

Super controversial.

25

: 00:01:05

So we dive into that in that episode.

26

: 00:01:06

And then jump training is

27

: 00:01:08

The secret sister that no

one really talks about.

28

: 00:01:10

So we chat about jump training and how

beneficial it is for us as women in

29

: 00:01:14

the previous episode and this week.

30

: 00:01:16

Again, deviating a little bit talking

about zone two training and why it might

31

: 00:01:20

not be as essential as we previously

thought, especially for women.

32

: 00:01:24

So first of all, what

is zone two training?

33

: 00:01:26

Zone two training is exercising at about

60 to 70% of your max heart rate or a max

34

: 00:01:32

effort for a prolonged period of time.

35

: 00:01:35

As a reminder, in order to

calculate your max heart rate,

36

: 00:01:38

just do two 20 minus your age.

37

: 00:01:40

So for someone who's 20

years old, two 20 minus 20.

38

: 00:01:44

Estimated max heart rate would

be about 200 beats per minute.

39

: 00:01:47

So exercising in that 60 to 70%

range of that heart rate zone

40

: 00:01:52

will be your zone two training.

41

: 00:01:55

Another way to look at it that we were

taught in school is that you can maintain

42

: 00:01:57

a conversation but you can't sing.

43

: 00:01:59

So if you're able to speed walk and

talk but not sing, that is that zone

44

: 00:02:04

two moderate intensity training.

45

: 00:02:06

When it comes to zone two training, most

of the research done on zone two training

46

: 00:02:11

has been done on men, which is why I

wanted to dive into this topic today.

47

: 00:02:15

Historically speaking, it's it's been

recommended to get about 45 to 90

48

: 00:02:19

minutes of zone two training five times

a week, but a lot of that research

49

: 00:02:23

has been done on the male body.

50

: 00:02:25

so we'll dive into how that

contrasts with the female body.

51

: 00:02:29

What are the benefits of zone two

training from an overarching perspective?

52

: 00:02:34

One, of course, cardiovascular

benefits, heart health is huge, and

53

: 00:02:37

zone two really does help with that.

54

: 00:02:39

We also have the benefits of fat

oxidation and improved metabolism, and

55

: 00:02:44

then we also can use zone two as active

recovery and mental health benefits of.

56

: 00:02:48

So those are the overarching

benefits of zone two training

57

: 00:02:51

for both men and for women.

58

: 00:02:53

So what are some reasons we might

not wanna do zone two training and

59

: 00:02:56

might wanna choose another form of

cardiovascular exercise to sort one of

60

: 00:03:00

the cons is time inefficiency and guilt.

61

: 00:03:03

It takes a good amount of time to

exercise for as long as we need to.

62

: 00:03:07

At 60 to 70% of our max heart rate,

it's pretty easy to get to that 60, 70%.

63

: 00:03:12

So in order to get those benefits.

64

: 00:03:14

That we talked about, the

cardiovascular benefits, the

65

: 00:03:16

metabolic benefits, all of that.

66

: 00:03:17

We need to exercise for a very long

period of time, and someone might feel

67

: 00:03:22

a little bit guilty not reaching that 90

minutes, five times a week recommendation

68

: 00:03:27

that we've historically adopted.

69

: 00:03:29

there's also limited stimulus for

adaptation, especially as we age.

70

: 00:03:33

It is not hard enough exercise to help

with muscle mass or bone Mineral density,

71

: 00:03:37

which we've already discussed, are

both things that we want to focus on,

72

: 00:03:41

especially as we age, and it's not easy

enough to be active recovery, so it falls

73

: 00:03:45

in this sort of like gray middle zone.

74

: 00:03:48

With prolonged exercise, we can

have sustained cortisol increases.

75

: 00:03:51

So if you're someone who has a high

baseline level of cortisol anyways,

76

: 00:03:56

whether through work, stress, family

stress, life stress, just you're a

77

: 00:04:00

chronic zone two exerciser where you're

doing that 90 minutes five times a week

78

: 00:04:05

at 60 to 70% of your max heart rate,

you can have elevated cortisol levels

79

: 00:04:09

for a more prolonged period of time.

80

: 00:04:11

So extended moderate intensity exercise,

especially when combined with other

81

: 00:04:16

stressors in life, can lead to elevated

cortisol levels, especially in women.

82

: 00:04:20

Now let's zoom in a little bit more

specifically on why the female physiology

83

: 00:04:26

differs from the male physiology when

it comes to zone two training women

84

: 00:04:30

in general, as we mentioned in the

first essential series, have natural.

85

: 00:04:37

superior mitochondrial

function than men do,

86

: 00:04:40

we have more oxidative, meaning they

use oxygen type one skeletal muscle

87

: 00:04:45

fibers that have a high mitochondrial

density and we actually have about

88

: 00:04:49

a third greater mitochondrial

respiration as women compared to men.

89

: 00:04:53

Women are also much more

metabolically flexible than men.

90

: 00:04:56

We switch between.

91

: 00:04:58

Utilizing carbs and fats

as fuel quicker than men.

92

: 00:05:02

So a lot of the time men will do zone

two training to switch from that glucose,

93

: 00:05:06

that carbohydrate fuel utilization to fat.

94

: 00:05:09

For fat loss.

95

: 00:05:10

As women, we are actually really

good at switching, and so we don't

96

: 00:05:12

necessarily need as long of that

time at that moderate intensity

97

: 00:05:16

to switch to that fat utilization.

98

: 00:05:18

We do it relatively

quickly compared to a male.

99

: 00:05:21

We're able to oxidize more fat and

less carbs than men during prolonged

100

: 00:05:25

exercise at a similar intensity.

101

: 00:05:27

We maintain a better cellular

energy homeostasis during exercise

102

: 00:05:31

stress, and we have better built-in

fat burning efficiency, which

103

: 00:05:34

is basically that fat oxidation.

104

: 00:05:36

We have a greater abundance of fatty

acid transporters, meaning we're

105

: 00:05:40

better able to use those fatty acids.

106

: 00:05:43

Because we have more of that transporter

to utilize those fatty acids as energy.

107

: 00:05:47

We also have more stored fat within

our muscles, which is easier to access

108

: 00:05:51

compared to fat stored in other places.

109

: 00:05:53

And so we're better able to tap

in to the fat, stored in muscle

110

: 00:05:57

to utilize that for energy.

111

: 00:05:58

And we have better mechanisms

for utilizing fat as fuel too.

112

: 00:06:01

So because of our.

113

: 00:06:04

Mitochondrial density

being higher than men.

114

: 00:06:07

We also have more metabolic

flexibility able to switch

115

: 00:06:11

between carbohydrates and fats.

116

: 00:06:13

Zone two might not be as necessary for us.

117

: 00:06:15

Since a few of the primary pros and

reasons to do zone two training is

118

: 00:06:19

to train the mitochondria and utilize

fat for body composition changes.

119

: 00:06:23

The fact that our bodies are already

structured to do that makes zone two may

120

: 00:06:28

be less of a priority for us as women.

121

: 00:06:29

It's not that it's bad for us, not at all.

122

: 00:06:32

It's just that when building our

exercise handbags of essentials.

123

: 00:06:36

The essentials we need in our routine,

why would we include something that

124

: 00:06:41

takes so much time and that our body is

already naturally adapted for, rather than

125

: 00:06:46

incorporating some of the other essentials

that we actually need, like high intensity

126

: 00:06:50

interval training and sprint interval

training that our bodies aren't as

127

: 00:06:54

set up for as our male counterparts.

128

: 00:06:57

High intensity interval training and

sprint interval training have also

129

: 00:07:00

been shown to be more beneficial in the

cardiovascular and metabolic realms.

130

: 00:07:06

With less of a time commitment.

131

: 00:07:08

So overall it's about bang for your buck.

132

: 00:07:09

If you really enjoy

zone two cardio, do it.

133

: 00:07:12

By all means, it's wonderful as long as

you have the appropriate cool down and

134

: 00:07:16

the appropriate recovery in between.

135

: 00:07:18

Zone two is great, and I'm not

discouraging at all, but if we're really

136

: 00:07:21

trying to build that exercise handbags of

purely essentials that we can do across

137

: 00:07:25

the board, it might be better bang for

your buck to incorporate another form

138

: 00:07:29

of cardiovascular and metabolic based

activities like high intensity interval

139

: 00:07:33

training and sprint interval training.

140

: 00:07:35

So there are exceptions, of course.

141

: 00:07:36

If you're training for something

long duration, lower intensity, or

142

: 00:07:41

moderate intensity, like a marathon,

of course you need to do zone training.

143

: 00:07:44

Specificity of training does matter, so

if you're training for something that

144

: 00:07:49

is moderate intensity, long duration,

you are going to want to include zone

145

: 00:07:53

two training in your current routine

for that training block, for that race

146

: 00:07:58

or event that you're training for.

147

: 00:08:00

As I was researching for this

episode, I came across another sort

148

: 00:08:04

of training mindset when it comes to

cardiovascular training that I thought

149

: 00:08:07

would be interesting to you guys too.

150

: 00:08:09

It basically talks about polarized

training for cardiovascular training where

151

: 00:08:14

if you can think of polarized opinions or.

152

: 00:08:17

Polar opposites.

153

: 00:08:18

They're on either side of the spectrum.

154

: 00:08:20

So this research argues that especially

for women, it's really good if we spend

155

: 00:08:25

the majority of our time in that black and

white zone on either end of the spectrum,

156

: 00:08:30

not as much in that gray area, not as

much in that moderate intensity area.

157

: 00:08:34

They advocate for spending time on either

side of the extreme, so 75 to 80% lower

158

: 00:08:40

intensity training, less than 10% of

moderate intensity training like zone

159

: 00:08:44

two, so not as much of that gray area,

and then 15 to 20% high intensity training

160

: 00:08:49

mixed, of course, with strength training.

161

: 00:08:51

And so thinking of that polarized training

model being super beneficial for women,

162

: 00:08:55

knowing that we're spending time on

either sides of the extremes and not as

163

: 00:08:59

much in that gray area, that middle zone.

164

: 00:09:02

So there are a lot of studies showing

benefit in the twenties and thirties,

165

: 00:09:05

forties and fifties, and 50 plus

age ranges for women utilizing this

166

: 00:09:10

polarized training, especially with

improving your metabolism, improving

167

: 00:09:14

fat utilization, body fat reduction,

and improved power and endurance.

168

: 00:09:18

So thinking of that as an alternative to

this prolonged, moderate intensity work,

169

: 00:09:23

working on either side of that spectrum

with that polarized training model.

170

: 00:09:27

So how do we incorporate it

into our exercise handbag?

171

: 00:09:31

Knowing what we know now and knowing

that zone two is maybe a little bit

172

: 00:09:34

more optional than what we previously

thought, especially for women.

173

: 00:09:37

If you wanna include zone training

because you enjoy it, not necessarily

174

: 00:09:40

training for anything specific, limit it

to about one to two sessions per week.

175

: 00:09:45

You can also use it for active

recovery in between your main sessions.

176

: 00:09:48

It shouldn't be the primary focus of your

cardiovascular training, but of course

177

: 00:09:52

you can use it for mental health reasons.

178

: 00:09:54

If you wanna try more of a polarized

training model, exercising in

179

: 00:09:57

those black and white zones and

not as much in that gray zone.

180

: 00:10:00

Shoot for 30 minutes of walking each day.

181

: 00:10:02

Again, that's that lower intensity range.

182

: 00:10:04

And then 15 to 25 minute high

intensity interval training

183

: 00:10:07

sessions about two to three times

per week on non-consecutive days.

184

: 00:10:11

As we talked about in our essentials

course in our first episode of the

185

: 00:10:15

Exercise Handbag Essentials series.

186

: 00:10:17

And if you do want to exercise in that

zone two range because you enjoy it,

187

: 00:10:22

because it's easy to do with a friend.

188

: 00:10:24

Always think, am I in zone two?

189

: 00:10:26

am I able to carry on a

conversation without singing?

190

: 00:10:28

That's a really good gauge as

to know whether or not you truly

191

: 00:10:31

are in that zone two range.

192

: 00:10:33

So jogging with friends, cycling around

your neighborhood at a leisurely place.

193

: 00:10:37

Dance, cardio, sculpt flow

classes, Pilates flow classes.

194

: 00:10:40

Always you can incorporate zone two

training if you enjoy it, if it's

195

: 00:10:43

something that you really love to do.

196

: 00:10:45

Knowing that it's not necessarily

essential and definitely not a

197

: 00:10:48

foundational element for our exercise

handbags, especially as women.

198

: 00:10:52

I know that probably

surprised some of you.

199

: 00:10:54

I hope you enjoyed this episode.

200

: 00:10:56

I hope you learned more why our bodies as

women might not respond as well to zone

201

: 00:11:00

two training as men or might not need

it as much as our male counterparts do.

202

: 00:11:05

But I hope you learned something.

203

: 00:11:06

I hope you enjoyed this episode.

204

: 00:11:08

I hope you're enjoying this series so far.

205

: 00:11:09

I'd love to hear from you guys to see

what you've learned and how you're

206

: 00:11:12

incorporating it into your own routines.

207

: 00:11:15

But thank you guys so much for listening,

and I'll see you guys again on the next

208

: 00:11:18

episode of Wellness Fixes of the Pod.