60:: health & wellness propaganda I will absolutely NOT be falling for (& neither should you!)
Wellness girl chat with us about health & wellness propaganda you should absolutely NOT be falling for. We chat the big protein push, “manifesting fertility”, creatine, greens powders, pilates, and more! Listen in as we take it back to some of our more lighthearted wellness girl chats!
Links::
Creatine for Mama & Baby with Dr. Stacey Ellery (Mamapalooza Episode)
49:: female-specific fueling, training, and performance with Dr. Katie Hirsch
Cortisol Series::
31:: all about cortisol, the misunderstood "mean girl" hormone
32:: tips & tricks to balance your cortisol
Inflammation series::
35:: all about inflammation & why its necessary for our bodies
36:: inflammation's role in muscle building, acne, and gut health
38:: how inflammation impacts your menstrual cycle
Thorne Website:: https://s.thorne.com/Zgk7Y
My Thorne Dispensary & Recs:: https://www.thorne.com/u/drkelsyvickdpt
Message me for 35% off your Thorne orders!
loving the pod? click the follow button, & we'd love if you could leave a review!
website:: elaa-wellness.com
insta:: @dr.kelsyvickdpt & @elaa_wellness & @wellnessbigsispod
youtube:: @dr.kelsyvickdpt
tiktok:: @dr.kelsyvickdpt
sign up for the free wellness big sis newsletter!
sign up for our patreon for exclusive content & workouts!
00:18 – 00:42 Introduction to Health and Wellness Propaganda
00:43 – 01:31 Recap of MamaPalooza Podcast Festival
01:32 – 03:17 Upcoming Episodes and Special Guests
03:18 – 04:00 Health and Wellness Propaganda: What Not to Fall For
04:01 – 04:37 The Protein Push: Why It's Not the Only Macro
04:38 – 06:49 Intermittent Fasting for Women: The Real Deal
06:50 – 08:37 Aesthetic Goals: Why They Shouldn't Be Demonized
09:29 – 11:14 Manifesting Fertility: The Controversy
11:15 – 13:06 Variety in Workouts: Why It's Essential
13:07 – 15:02 Creatine Marketing: Separating Fact from Fiction
15:03 – 19:06 Greens Powders and Supplements: Buyer Beware
19:07 – 19:51 Cycle Syncing: The Misconceptions
19:52 – 20:34 Inflammation and Cortisol: The Good Side
20:35 – 23:56 Conclusion and Future Plans
Mentioned in this episode:
Thorne Website:: https://s.thorne.com/Zgk7Y My Thorne Dispensary & Recs:: https://www.thorne.com/u/drkelsyvickdpt Message me for 35% off your Thorne orders!:: https://www.instagram.com/direct/t/17842574915346652
Transcript
There's a trend going around on TikTok
right now that talks about propaganda
2
:we are absolutely not falling for.
3
:So let's take a little bit of a health
and wellness approach to that and talk
4
:about some of the health and wellness
propaganda that we are not falling for.
5
:Welcome back to Wellness Big Sis, the Pod.
6
:I'm your host, Dr.
7
:Kelsy Vick, a board certified orthopedic
doctor of physical therapy, a pelvic floor
8
:physical therapist, and the owner and
founder of the elää Wellness Sisterhood.
9
:And we have just wrapped up our
Mama Palooza podcast festival
10
:throughout the month of May where
we covered topics like creatine sex.
11
:Breastfeeding male fertility and
how your man's health can actually
12
:affect your pregnancy symptoms.
13
:And then obviously the health
of the child and so much more.
14
:So if you are pregnant, curious if you
are pregnant, if you are postpartum.
15
:If you're just curious about learning
a little bit more on the female body, I
16
:encourage you to check out those episodes.
17
:They're all titled like Mama Palooza.
18
:And then the episode
title with the experts.
19
:So we called it a Women's
Health Podcast festival.
20
:It was so much fun, but it was definitely
a lot of heavy hitting learning and a lot
21
:of expert interviews and just learning
the truth and research of our bodies.
22
:So the next two weeks we'll cover some
more, just like fun, lighthearted,
23
:I say girly episodes just because I
love looking at some of these trends.
24
:I love some of the health and wellness,
just like fun podcast episodes where
25
:we just kind of girl chat about things.
26
:So that's what these next
two weeks will be about.
27
:And then the third week in June,
we are actually releasing a super
28
:special episode with a traditional
Chinese medicine doctor, Dr.
29
:Felice Chan,
30
:I actually found her while scrolling
at TikTok one day, and she was
31
:talking about the traditional
Chinese medicine perspective on our
32
:periods and on the menstrual cycle.
33
:And I was like, oh my gosh, she's
providing such a unique perspective.
34
:And so I immediately reached out
to see if she'd come on the podcast
35
:and she was so kind and agreeing.
36
:So that episode will come out in
three weeks, I guess like middle of
37
:June, whatever that Monday is like.
38
:The 15th or 16th, something like that.
39
:But stay tuned for that episode
'cause it is so wonderful.
40
:It is like jam packed with a lot of topics
that we talk about, like acne, gut health,
41
:bloating, digestion with traveling.
42
:The menstrual cycle, like all of
these topics that we care about, but
43
:from an entirely new perspective,
and I absolutely love that interview.
44
:So the newsletter that actually
came out today, the magazine
45
:style newsletter that we do every
month came out today and it has.
46
:A blog post article with her answering
questions about her journey, about the
47
:traditional Chinese medicine perspective
on certain things, and then her
48
:traditional Chinese medicine toolkit.
49
:So I will link those posts below
just in case you're not signed
50
:up for our newsletter, and you
can still read what she says and
51
:just get excited for that episode.
52
:But until then, we'll keep it
fun, lighthearted and girly.
53
:So today we'll talk about some of the
health and wellness propaganda that
54
:I'm not falling for, that I don't
think you should be falling for either.
55
:And I call it propaganda only
because it's a trend on TikTok.
56
:And I guess there's some controversy
around the term, which, yes, like it's
57
:not true propaganda, but it's a fun
way to put hot terminology to some of
58
:these things that we just don't agree
with or that I just don't agree with
59
:when it comes to health and wellness,
especially as it's targeted for women.
60
:So I've loved seeing what other
people say on theirs, and It spans a
61
:lot of categories, so it's not just
health and wellness, but since this
62
:is the Wellness Big Sis podcast, I
figured we'd narrow in on health and
63
:wellness topics and health and wellness
propaganda that I am not falling for.
64
:So the first one is a big
one, especially in the US and
65
:that is the push for protein.
66
:Protein as the only macro
that we should care about.
67
:I'm definitely not falling for that.
68
:What about fats?
69
:What about carbs?
70
:What about needing fats
for hormonal balance?
71
:What about fiber for all sorts
of like regulation of our system?
72
:What about carbs for not only like muscle
fuel and like just fuel and energy in
73
:general, but especially brain fuel?
74
:So protein as the only
thing we should be tracking.
75
:The only thing we should be caring
about that is definitely propaganda.
76
:I am not falling for.
77
:The second one is intermittent fasting
for women, and I just got back from a
78
:family vacation and my sister and her
boyfriend were both bringing this up to
79
:me, and my sister was like, please tell
him why intermittent fasting, why fasting
80
:in general is not recommended for women.
81
:And I'm gonna say.
82
:Most women in general, just
the way that our physiology is.
83
:But I know there are some autoimmune
conditions and things like that
84
:might benefit from intermittent
fasting, but this is just on a
85
:very basic physiological scale.
86
:Fasting for women, and especially fasting
before a workout, is not something
87
:that we should be doing as women based
on how our physiology and how our.
88
:Body taps into different resources.
89
:So we talked a lot about
this on episode 49 with Dr.
90
:Katie Hirsh.
91
:So I'll link that episode below just
in case you wanna hear her explanation.
92
:But from a high level perspective,
women have a lower threshold than
93
:men for when they start to kick in
to resources that they actually need.
94
:So for example, if we're working out.
95
:Early in the morning, fasted
without any sort of fuel.
96
:Our body is going to sense this
danger almost to where it kicks
97
:in to pull resources from things
that we actually need, like muscle.
98
:So our bodies start to break down
muscle a lot quicker than men
99
:because our body's threshold for
100
:That perception of danger or
low fuel reserve that our bodies
101
:have, it just overall has a lower
threshold than a man's body does.
102
:And so we start to mobilize
resources that we actually wanna
103
:hold onto, like muscle a lot quicker.
104
:So if we can prefuel with glucose,
carbs with protein before a workout.
105
:We give our body that message that,
Hey, we have enough resources now
106
:pull from these resources rather
than starting to pull from the muscle
107
:tissue that we actually wanna keep.
108
:So fueling even a little bit before your
workout is highly recommended, especially
109
:for women because again, that threshold
is just a little bit lower than it is for
110
:men, and usually men can do more of those
fasted workouts or intermittent fasting.
111
:So I'll again leave that episode below
if you guys wanna check that out.
112
:I will also not be falling for the
demonization of aesthetic goals.
113
:I feel like there's this whole push and
there's been this sort of pendulum swing
114
:from not focusing on aesthetic goals,
115
:So almost shaming girls who might
want to have a wed shred or something
116
:before their wedding or get more toned
or lose a little bit of body fat or
117
:lose that lower belly pooch or lose
fat in certain areas of their body and
118
:no, we can't spot treat that fat, but.
119
:I don't want to demonize aesthetic goals.
120
:I have aesthetic goals, like I
wanna look good, I wanna feel
121
:good, and that is totally okay.
122
:I don't like this push where your
goals can only be related to strength
123
:or power or feeling good in your
body, which all are so important.
124
:But I just don't think we should be
demonizing goals of any kind, especially
125
:if they're coming from a good place of
just wanting to feel better in our bodies.
126
:People's goals and what gets them up and
moving and choosing healthy behaviors.
127
:I don't like demonizing any goals
related to that, but I see it mostly
128
:in regards to aesthetic goals.
129
:Also as a signed note, so many of the
men in my life, they're like, yeah, I
130
:wanna build more muscle in this area.
131
:Like they just talk about these
aesthetic goals, or, yeah, I wanna
132
:tone my legs up, or I wanna get a
little bit larger in my chest area.
133
:Like whatever it is, it just doesn't
seem to be demonized as much in men
134
:as it is in women, like women caring
about the way that they look is, I'm
135
:using the word demonize, which might
be a little bit strong, but it's the
136
:first word that came to mind because.
137
:People do seem to have strong opinions
about how women feel about their bodies
138
:and women whose goals might just revolve
around aesthetics compared to improved
139
:energy, improved sleep, feeling more
confident, feeling more self-assured,.
140
:There's a wide range of reasons why
someone might choose to pursue health
141
:and wellness routines, and I don't
think we should be demonizing anyone for
142
:any of the goals that gets them up and
moving and choosing healthy behaviors.
143
:The next one.
144
:I've heard one creator talk about
this and she's been getting a lot
145
:of heat for it, which rightfully so.
146
:I think, and that is regarding
manifesting fertility.
147
:So I'm not gonna take the words out
of her mouth, but the way that it
148
:was portrayed was that just putting
your mindset and putting your body
149
:in the right mental space and the
right mindfulness space to accept a
150
:baby and to accept conception and.
151
:Accept a healthy pregnancy is
all you need to do when you
152
:are struggling with fertility.
153
:And it came off as her saying, the people
who are struggling with infertility are
154
:just not putting their head in the right
space to accept that pregnancy and it
155
:just came off in a really wrong way.
156
:And there's so many other.
157
:Things that go into infertility besides
just wanting to accept your body and open
158
:your body to be open for this pregnancy.
159
:So I definitely am not going to be falling
for that propaganda of just manifesting
160
:fertility because I've seen so many other
creators coming out against this saying.
161
:We have male factor infertility, so
me opening my body up to a pregnancy
162
:is not going to solve the male factor
infertility that we're struggling with.
163
:So it was just
164
:a little shortsighted, I think it
was probably coming from a good place
165
:because she portrayed it as wanting
to share the good and the positives
166
:of pregnancy, but I think there was a
little bit of a miss when it came to.
167
:How she presented the information.
168
:So manifesting fertility is not
something that I will be falling for
169
:because there's so much that goes into
fertility other than just manifesting it
170
:and being mindful about it and opening
your body to the chance for pregnancy.
171
:See.
172
:I also won't be falling for the
propaganda of Pilates for every
173
:workout five days, six days a week, or
honestly, strength training for every
174
:workout or running for every workout.
175
:We need variety.
176
:Our body needs variety.
177
:Yes, there needs to be some consistency.
178
:If we have more of these like
toning and aesthetic goals where.
179
:Our muscles do respond to consistency
over time, but it also responds to
180
:periodization is what we call it, where
it's varying the loads and the stimulus
181
:that we're placing on our bodies.
182
:So we need speed, we need
strength, we need power.
183
:We need cardiovascular endurance.
184
:We need stabilization.
185
:We need balance.
186
:We need deep core control.
187
:We need.
188
:Reactionary and anticipatory balance.
189
:We need all of these other things that
one specific workout, no matter if it's
190
:Pilates or strength or running or swimming
or whatever, workout one workout for
191
:all of your workouts is not necessarily
going to be beneficial for your body.
192
:Not only for the lack of adaptation
for our bodies, but also for.
193
:the risk for injury coming from my
little physical therapist heart.
194
:If you're doing the same thing over and
over again and not varying patterns,
195
:you're more likely to have an overuse
injury or something where doing
196
:the same thing over and over again.
197
:Put some of your joints
and muscles at risk.
198
:So our body needs variety and
variety can be a lot of things.
199
:It can be Pilates and walks
and runs and strength.
200
:It can be a mix and sprinkle of
all sorts of activities, but our
201
:bodies really do thrive on variety
202
:. Especially when it comes
to just overall longevity.
203
:Although disclaimer, you do need
consistency with your strength training,
204
:but that doesn't mean you have to do
five days a week for the same things.
205
:It just means incorporating similar
movements over time so that you are
206
:building muscle in the way that you want,
in the muscles that you want, and that
207
:you're giving the muscles enough stimulus
in order for those adaptations to occur.
208
:So I also will not be falling for the
marketing behind creatine and this
209
:new wave of marketing behind creatine,
especially the creatine makes you bulky
210
:or creatine for women type of marketing
that I'm seeing all over the place.
211
:Creatine has been studied for decades,
and there are some wonderful researchers
212
:who are contributing to a resource that
was mentioned in our Mama Palooza podcast
213
:festival called Creatine for Health.
214
:That strips away all of the social
media, all of the marketing to really
215
:help us learn the truth behind creatine.
216
:I read this week that creatine
by:
217
:billion industry.
218
:So knowing all of these marketing
terms that are coming up, like
219
:creatine for a woman like creatine,
making you bulky or toning you
220
:up, I'm just not falling for it.
221
:Creatine is something that occurs
naturally within our bodies.
222
:It's a supplement that
has been studied for.
223
:Many decades, and I'll put the resource
that she mentioned below in addition
224
:to the podcast where we've talked about
creatine before, just in case you are
225
:also confused on who to trust, because
this resource creatine for health,
226
:pulls together a lot of researchers
and a lot of the top experts within
227
:the creatine field in order to answer
some of the general populations.
228
:Questions and then also supply like
research studies for you to look into
229
:to see what is the truth behind creatine
versus what's just shiny marketing.
230
:So there's two episodes that we've done,
three really that mention creatine.
231
:So I'll leave all of those links below.
232
:And I have added chapters, so if you're
just like, I wanna learn about the
233
:creatine section, just skip through
those chapters and we cover it.
234
:A good amount of detail for just
the female body and then also for
235
:the female body during pregnancy
and the health of the baby.
236
:So super cool episodes.
237
:And we had two researchers on for
those episodes, which they are just
238
:so wonderful and shared such great
insight and to the truth behind
239
:creatine for our female bodies.
240
:I also won't be falling for greens powders
and heavily marketed supplement companies.
241
:So similar to the previous,
propaganda, I'm not falling for, but.
242
:Do your due diligence when it comes
to some of these supplement companies.
243
:If you are getting a lot of ads for
a particular greens company or a
244
:particular supplement company, try
and think how much of their budget
245
:and how much of what you're paying for
is going into their marketing, going
246
:into their r and d, going into their
product development, their supply chain,
247
:their packaging, all of these things
and start to see okay, if I'm getting.
248
:One of these ads every 10 minutes that
is going to say something about how much
249
:of the cost that I'm paying for their
product is going into marketing versus
250
:actually going into some of the testing,
the third party testing that's recommended
251
:for supplements to make sure that
252
:what they're saying is in them is what
is actually in them and doing what we
253
:actually think it's supposed to be doing.
254
:So I like to think of it from that lens.
255
:I also like to look, are
the founders trained?
256
:Are they MDs?
257
:Are they PharmDs?
258
:Do they have high level degrees that
are giving them the background to create
259
:This supplement or greens powder.
260
:If the founder doesn't seem
to have that training, do they
261
:have at least a medical board?
262
:I have no doubt that some of these
founders have the best intentions based
263
:on their medical history and their health
history for creating these supplements.
264
:But are they at least relying on the
expertise of trained professionals
265
:who paid a lot and went through
a ton of school in order to learn
266
:the ins and outs of all of these
compounds and interactions together?
267
:So I'll bring up a supplement company
that I've talked about before on
268
:our Patreon and I went in detail
about my thoughts on this particular
269
:company, but it is the arrae creatine
gummies, specifically called Tone.
270
:So I talk about all my opinions
on that other video, but we.
271
:Also deep dived into the cost per serving
compared to other creatine options
272
:And we figured out the cost comes out
to $2 and 75 cents a serving with one
273
:gram of added sugar because they're
creatine gummies for the arrae.
274
:Creatine gummies compared to Thorne,
which is my favorite, creatine, and
275
:the one that I always recommend, comes
out to about 30 cents per serving.
276
:In my luteal phase I creatine load, which
has been shown to help not only with
277
:like performance and power and getting
those extra few reps in your exercise
278
:and training sessions, but it's also been
shown to help pull the water into the
279
:muscles to decrease some of the bloating
280
:I experience an luteal phase and that
you might experience an luteal phase.
281
:And so if we do 2 75 times four servings,
which is what I have, so five grams,
282
:four servings a day, 20 grams, that's
almost $12 a day on just creatine if
283
:you're taking the creatine gummies.
284
:And that's four grams of added
sugar, where with thorn, 30
285
:cents times four servings a day.
286
:In that loading phase.
287
:Is a dollar 20.
288
:So it just goes to show the differences
in the branding, the brands.
289
:And the thorn one is also
third party tested, where the
290
:arrae creatine ones are not.
291
:And so third party tested
again, is of a higher standard.
292
:It's also 30 cents a serving compared
to $2 and 75 cents a serving.
293
:So just something to be more
mindful of when you are shopping for
294
:supplements and greens powders and
just things to add to your routine.
295
:As a side note, I do the same thing
with clothing now, after my husband
296
:started being more mindful of the
clothes that I buy and the fiber content
297
:that they're made of, and props to him
because I had never thought of that.
298
:I just bought for looks, but now I'm
looking more into polyester versus linen
299
:versus silk versus cotton fibers, and.
300
:Is what I'm paying for actually
worth it based on the fiber content.
301
:And he points it out every time I go
shopping and he's dragged along with me.
302
:So it's very helpful actually when
it comes to both clothing, but
303
:then also your medicine cabinet
and your supplement cabinet.
304
:So I'm also not falling for cycle
syncing as it's typically referred to.
305
:You don't have to eat a
certain way during your cycle.
306
:You don't have to work out a
certain way during your cycle.
307
:You can adjust and modify some of these
things, but truly understanding what's
308
:happening within your body will help you
make those decisions to know, oh, I'm
309
:feeling extra inflamed and extra bloated.
310
:Maybe that's why I'm going to start.
311
:Implementing a little bit more berries
or anti-inflammatory foods or, Hey,
312
:I'm recovering a little poorer in
my luteal phase after a workout, so
313
:maybe I do back off the weights or
reps a little bit, but not necessarily
314
:having to do strictly yoga or eat
strictly these types of nuts or seeds
315
:in a particular phase of your cycles.
316
:So cycle sinking as it's
typically referred to as
317
:propaganda, I am not falling for.
318
:And then lastly, the demonization
of inflammation and cortisol
319
:is something I am definitely
not falling for inflammation.
320
:The primary purpose is to help kickstart
the healing process within your body.
321
:Cortisol's needed for muscle building.
322
:There's so many good things that happen
from inflammation and from cortisol,
323
:and we need both within our bodies.
324
:We've done a whole series on
that, so I'll link those below.
325
:If you wanna dive in a little bit deeper
to what does inflammation actually mean?
326
:Why is it a good thing in
my body and in your body
327
:and the same thing with cortisol.
328
:Why do we need it?
329
:Why is it in our body?
330
:Why is there such a fear around
cortisol and inflammation?
331
:And what can we do about it if we
do get stuck in this inflammatory
332
:cycle or this high cortisol cycle?
333
:So I'll leave those episodes of the
series we did back in the fall below.
334
:So I think this was a longer
episode than what I thought.
335
:I guess I have a lot of propaganda
that I don't want to fall for when it
336
:comes to health and wellness topics.
337
:But I hope you guys enjoyed this episode.
338
:I wanna say a huge thank you to all of
those who supported the podcast festival,
339
:who listened to the podcast festival,
who shared all the episodes, who texted
340
:me or messaged me in some way and said.
341
:Oh my gosh.
342
:Thank you for this episode.
343
:I learned so much from this,
like it truly means the world.
344
:And I have made sure to pass on
all of those messages to the guest
345
:experts that we had on because
a lot of them are researchers.
346
:And I feel like as a clinician,
I get feedback a lot.
347
:I get a lot of gift cards, I
get a lot of thank you cards.
348
:I get a lot of praise, from
patients, and it feels so, so good.
349
:And I feel like some of
these researchers that are.
350
:At the tops of their field, might not hear
that from people in the general public.
351
:So any message that you've sent me,
any message that I've got, any praise
352
:for their episode, I have made sure
to send it to them so that they also
353
:know that their work is appreciated.
354
:So thank you guys so much.
355
:It means the world to me, but I also
know it means the world to them.
356
:My goal is to always make this podcast
super fun but filled with valuable,
357
:truthful information, focusing on our
female bodies in health and wellness.
358
:'cause there's so much nonsense out there.
359
:So my goal is to make this a
super trusted, a super valuable
360
:resource for all of you guys.
361
:So throughout the summer, I am
actually going to take a break
362
:from some of the hotter and smarter
episodes, which are our mini episodes
363
:that I absolutely love doing.
364
:But I have been praying about
guidance on next steps and just
365
:ways to make this podcast better.
366
:And I have been feeling a pull to cut
back a little bit on some of those
367
:episodes just throughout the summer so
that I can focus more on spreading the
368
:word and connecting with more people who
might be able to help further my goal
369
:and my mission with this podcast, so
370
:the hotter and smarter in five
episodes will return in the fall.
371
:I am sorry if those are some of your
favorite episodes because I really do
372
:love filming them and recording them,
and it's really hard for me to pull
373
:back on something that I know is super
beneficial, but for some reason, and
374
:I know it's a reason that I cannot
quite see yet, God's pulling me to
375
:take back that time for those episodes
and put it into other opportunities.
376
:So I thank you guys for all of your
support, for all of you guys listening
377
:to every episode that I release, but
just through the summer as we all like
378
:vacation and spend time with our families
and take a little bit of an exhale.
379
:I guess I'm feeling called to also
take an exhale by only releasing
380
:sort of our main episodes on Mondays.
381
:So it's just the hotter inspired episodes
that won't be released throughout the
382
:summer, but they will be back in the fall.
383
:And I'm hoping to have even more podcast
festival material too in the fall,
384
:like maybe a podcast festival focused
on some of the hot topics that we.
385
:Question as women when it comes
to our health and wellness.
386
:So if you guys have any ideas on a podcast
festival, or experts that you guys want
387
:me to reach out to, please let me know
'cause it's something that I had so
388
:much fun doing for MoMA and I would love
to do it again in the fall sometimes.
389
:I think that's all.
390
:Thank you guys so much
for all of your support.
391
:It truly means the world.
392
:Our Mama Palooza podcast
festival was a huge hit.
393
:It got shared to so many people from
across the world, and I'm so grateful.
394
:Thank you guys so much for your support
and I'll see you guys again on the next
395
:episode of Wellness Big Sis, the pod.